Drive It Pro vs. Rideshare Rental: Best Phoenix Rideshare Car Rental?

Phoenix is home to a variety of rideshare car rental services, each claiming to be the best option for drivers looking to maximize earnings on Uber, Lyft, or delivery platforms.

Rideshare Rental (known online at rideshare-cars.com) markets itself as the “#1 rideshare vehicle leasing & rental company in Phoenix” with over 30 years of transportation experience. They highlight flexible plans, a focus on maintenance, and 24-hour support—all great features.
But how do they actually compare to Drive It Pro, another West Van Buren–based rental provider that’s made waves by offering low upfront costs, rent-to-own opportunities, and hybrid vehicle fleets?

In this in-depth comparison of Drive It Pro vs Rideshare Rental, we’ll stack up Rideshare Rental’s claims against Drive It Pro’s proven advantages to see which one truly gives Phoenix drivers the best path to higher earnings and fewer headaches.

Pricing and Fees

Rideshare Rental

Rideshare Rental’s website doesn’t prominently list fixed weekly rates. Instead, they emphasize flexible payment plans and claim “affordable options” for drivers. They may require a deposit or a first-week payment up front, though exact details can be unclear.
Because there’s no published all-in-one weekly rate, drivers often have to contact Rideshare Rental directly for a quote—possibly leading to variability depending on the driver’s profile or length of rental.
Some user reports online suggest that after adding insurance or various administrative fees, the actual weekly cost can be on par with or higher than the Phoenix average (in the $300–$350/week range). If that’s true, the lower advertised rates might not always tell the whole story.

Drive It Pro

Straightforward Pricing: Drive It Pro charges a consistent weekly rate of $352.60/week for Grade A, $342.74/week Grade B (including tax), for a well-maintained hybrid. This typically comes out to about $352.95 total with tax.
Low Upfront Cost: Only $225 down to get started—much lower than most competitors. No big security deposit or multi-week fee required.
No Surprise Fees: Insurance approach is flexible; Drive It Pro helps drivers obtain a personal rideshare policy so it doesn’t tack on a high insurance fee to the weekly cost. If you already have a personal auto policy with a rideshare endorsement, you’re set. Otherwise, Drive It Pro’s partner insurance can get you covered quickly—often same-day.

Drive It Pro vs Rideshare Rental: Verdict on Pricing
If Rideshare Rental truly offers a lower base cost, that might attract drivers at first glance. However, because exact rates aren’t publicly displayed and may include extra fees or deposits, many drivers find themselves paying as much—or more—than Drive It Pro’s transparent $352.60/week (Grade A) or $341.74 (Grade B). Plus, Drive It Pro’s minimal upfront barrier ($225) stands out as a driver-friendly policy.

Vehicle Fleet and Quality

Rideshare Rental

Markets itself as experienced in “proper maintenance” and reliable vehicles. With “30+ years in transportation,” they likely have a sizeable fleet, though details are scarce online (the site is fairly minimal).
Vehicle age and fuel type vary. Some references mention standard sedans or older models, while others claim a focus on well-maintained cars. It’s unclear if they provide hybrids specifically.
Because they’re local, they probably rotate vehicles frequently, but the consistency (e.g., are they all under a certain mileage, or no older than 5 years?) isn’t transparently stated.

Drive It Pro

All-Hybrid Fleet: Drive It Pro focuses on Toyota Prius and other high-MPG hybrids. This single-model approach saves drivers on gas—often $20–$50/week less on fuel compared to a standard sedan.
Guaranteed Rideshare-Approved: Cars are explicitly vetted for Uber/Lyft compliance. No worry about the vehicle being too old or out-of-spec.
Well-Maintained: Because the fleet is specialized (Priuses), Drive It Pro’s on-site mechanics are hybrid specialists. Downtime is minimal, and repairs are quick.

Drive It Pro vs Rideshare Rental: Verdict on Vehicle Quality
While Rideshare Rental emphasizes maintenance, Drive It Pro’s hybrid-first strategy is a major edge, ensuring fuel savings and guaranteed platform approval. If Rideshare Rental uses older or standard sedans, drivers can expect bigger fuel bills and potential compliance issues over time.

Flexibility and Terms

Rideshare Rental

Touts “flexible plans” and “24-hour support,” but the specifics—like minimum rental length, deposit requirements, or platform restrictions—aren’t fully transparent on the site.
They may not restrict drivers to Uber or Lyft only; that’s good if you multi-app. However, details must be confirmed before signing.

Drive It Pro

Week-to-Week with No Long-Term Contract: You can rent for as short or long as you need. No locked-in multi-week deposit.
All Platforms: Use the car for Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, Instacart, Amazon Flex—no restrictions. Drive It Pro recognizes that being able to drive for multi-platforms is key to maximizing gig income.
Rent-to-Own Program: For those who stay long-term (48 months), you can own the vehicle outright (or get a $5k credit at Drive It Pro’s discretion). This is extremely rare among local competitors.
Flexible Insurance Approach: Because you carry your own liability insurance policy, you keep more control of coverage and can often save money over the bundled model.

Drive It Pro vs Rideshare Rental: Verdict on Terms
Both companies appear flexible, but Drive It Pro stands out for its no-strings approach (low down payment, no deposit), plus the rent-to-own option. If you plan to drive for a while, turning rental fees into equity is a huge advantage that Rideshare Rental does not advertise.

Maintenance & Support

Rideshare Rental

Claims “24-hour support” and a big emphasis on proper maintenance. Likely a plus for drivers, though we haven’t found many specifics or driver reviews about how quickly issues get handled if a car breaks down.
With a small online footprint, it’s unclear whether they have on-site mechanics or outsource repairs.

Drive It Pro

On-Site Mechanics: Drive It Pro operates a dedicated shop for their hybrid fleet. That means faster turnaround when you need repairs—often same-day or next-day.
6-Day Support: If issues pop up, Drive It Pro staff are reachable well beyond normal business hours. They know downtime = lost income for drivers, so they prioritize speed.
Insurance Guidance: If you need same-day rideshare insurance, Drive It Pro’s partners can typically get you covered within hours. That’s one less headache when you’re trying to start earning ASAP.

Drive It Pro vs Rideshare Rental: Verdict on Maintenance & Support
Rideshare Rental certainly claims strong maintenance and support, but Drive It Pro proves it with a specialized shop and extended support hours. This difference can be huge if a mechanical problem arises.

Drive It Pro vs Rideshare Rental Reputation & Reviews

Rideshare Rental

With minimal content online, it’s tough to gauge actual driver feedback from third-party review platforms. They claim “#1 in Phoenix,” but we couldn’t locate extensive public user reviews on well-known sites. It’s possible they rely on local referrals or direct marketing.
Having “been around since 2015” is a decent sign of some longevity, but drivers should dig deeper. Check if any reviews mention older vehicles, hidden fees, or slow support.

Drive It Pro

Known for consistently positive driver feedback—particularly praising the hybrid savings, straightforward costs, and friendly staff.
The company invests heavily in SEO and content, so you can read up on policies, rent-to-own details, and real testimonials at driveitpro.com.
Being just a few blocks away from Rideshare Rental on W. Van Buren, many local Phoenix drivers have physically compared the two. Drive It Pro’s reputation for reliability and transparency often wins them repeat business.

Verdict on Reputation
While Rideshare Rental says they’re #1, it’s not easy to verify from independent sources. Conversely, Drive It Pro has built a robust online presence, offers detailed info, and is well-regarded by local drivers. Transparency typically signals higher trust.

Unique Benefits of Drive It Pro

Why choose Drive It Pro vs Rideshare Rental? Here are some stand-out advantages:

Guaranteed Hybrid Fleet
- Get a Toyota Prius Gen III (or similar high-MPG hybrid) that saves $20–$50 a week on gas alone. Perfect for Uber/Lyft in a sprawling metro like Phoenix.
Low Start-Up Cost
- Only $225 to get on the road. Many other companies (including Rideshare Rental) may demand one or more full weeks of rent as a deposit.
Rent-to-Own Opportunity
- After 48 months of on-time rentals, you can own your car. Rideshare Rental doesn’t advertise any path to ownership, so your weekly payments never translate to a personal asset.
Transparent Pricing & Flexibility
- A consistent $325/week (plus tax), no hidden add-ons, and no forced deposit. You can multi-app across Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, and more.
Phoenix-Focused Support
- Drive It Pro’s on-site mechanics and extended support hours mean minimal downtime, a critical factor for busy rideshare drivers.

Drive It Pro vs Rideshare Rental Conclusion

Choosing a rideshare rental service can profoundly impact your daily earnings and long-term success in the gig economy. While Rideshare Rental highlights 30+ years in transportation and flexible plans, Drive It Pro consistently edges them out with:

Hybrid-only fleet for major fuel savings,
Low upfront (just $225) to start,
Rent-to-own for long-term asset building, and
Transparent policies that reduce surprises.

If you’re a Phoenix driver seeking the best combination of cost-effectiveness, support, and vehicle quality, look no further than Drive It Pro.

Ready to Hit the Road?

Reserve your rideshare car today and see why so many local drivers pick Drive It Pro over the competition.
Still have questions? Contact us or check out our FAQ to learn how we can help you start earning fast.

FAQ – Drive It Pro vs Rideshare Rental

Q: “Does Rideshare Rental really have 30 years’ experience?”
A: “They claim 30+ years of transportation experience, but detailed history isn’t clearly posted on rideshare-cars.com. Drivers may want to verify longevity and fleet age before committing.”
Q: “Which is cheaper: Drive It Pro or Rideshare Rental?”
A: “Drive It Pro has a transparent $352.60/week (for Group A) or $341.74/week (for Group B) rate with only $225 down, while Rideshare Rental’s exact pricing can vary. After all fees, they often end up at $300–$350/week. Drive It Pro can be more predictable and offers a hybrid fleet for gas savings.”
Q: “Can I drive for Uber and Lyft with Rideshare Rental?”
A: “They advertise flexible plans allowing multiple platforms, but read the fine print. Drive It Pro definitely lets you run Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, or any gig app with no restrictions.”
Q: “Does Rideshare Rental have a rent-to-own program?”
A: “Not publicly advertised. Drive It Pro, however, provides a 48-month rent-to-own path so you can eventually own your vehicle—unique among Phoenix-area rentals.”